Author(s)

Paul Wessling S.M.

Document Type

Musical Composition

Publication Date

10-1-1923

Publication Source

"Songs Marianists Used To Sing," edited by Brother Eugene Frank, S.M., page 15.

Description

This hymn is in the "alma mater" anthem style developed in the U.S. by the 1930s. This will strike some "contemporary" musicians as dated, but others will find it "classic." The lyrics are rhymed well, and the vocabulary is not as puerile as much of the music current in use liturgically and devotionally. This is a "soldiers of the Cross" theme in hymnody. The harmonic progressions and melodic passages are characteristic of English-language hymns written in the organ-accompanied march-like style of the early twentieth century. You may hear a variation on Brother Howard Hughes’ 200th Anniversary Anthem of 2011. It has an international aspect and indication of a vigorous Marianist present and future. This is essentially a well-crafted anthem. It is a call to work under the banner of Mary Immaculate and battle against Satan, not like knights of old fighting in foreign lands but right where we are today. (Abstract written by Father Ted Ley, S.M.)

Streaming Media

Keywords

knights, Mary Immaculate, Satan

Disciplines

Catholic Studies | Other Music | Religious Thought, Theology and Philosophy of Religion

Comments

Brother Howard Hughes, S.M.:

Paul Wessling Collection ... that dates it somewhat. Just a comment on the text ... it is dated 1923; that’s before I was born in 1930. Let me comment (for what it may be worth) on the text first and music afterward.

"Our captain" seems archaic; the same for “sally forth into the fray." Verse one seems like we are an army "marching" on toward heaven. Those images were seen in hymns in earlier times ... I guess because we were surrounded, so to speak, by warring nations and we considered our personal warring against Satan to be somewhat like that.

" ... strive to lead the souls of men" ... this sounds all right for men in the congregation, but ignores the women even in the same congregation. "Back then" it may have seemed all right, but nowadays the women in the congregation will feel passed over. The text seems influenced by "the battles of the day," and no doubt were fitting in those days of warring, but I think we should try to lose those phrases in our days.

The punctuation is rather loose in some spots—commas missing ... And in measure 16, the "rest" is awkwardly written for 4 beats to a measure. Even with the venerable name of Paul Wessling Collection, I find the text is awkward. Which came first, the text, or the “melody? Punctuation is a bit careless ... Is the piece worth saving at all? I don’t know if Paul Wessling did this setting of words and melody, or if he simply needed something for some occasion and this piece came easy-to-hand. This piece is simply "not finished." There isn’t even a double bar at the very end.

The writer seems to have "liked the text" but was in a hurry to fit text to music. I don’t think it is all that good a marriage. What came first, the text? The melody?

Comment from Nick Cardilino: In the measure which reads "sally forth into the fray," the words do not line up properly under the notes.

Language

English

Instrumentation

Voice

Musical Style

Hymn

Permission Statement

Made available with the permission of the Marianist Province of the United States. All rights reserved.

Chaminade _Our_Captain.mp3 (1421 kB)
Chaminade Our Captain


Share

COinS